| Hackettstown in the News 2023 edition | 78 | Bug3 | 3 weeks |
| Found Kitty | 1 | Sandi | 3 weeks |
| Missing Dog | 3 | Victoria Gentry | 3 weeks |
| Osa Electronics closed for good? | 34 | Timothy Mischka | 3 weeks |
| Trick or Treaters | 3 | summerrain | 4 weeks |
| Credit card surcharge | 36 | The Man | 4 weeks |
| Out of state moving company please | 4 | Nathalie | Nov 2nd |
| New Tea shop | 14 | Outdoor Women | Nov 2nd |
| I'm Happy Because II | 189 | positive | Nov 2nd |
| Sizzle closing | 6 | Sport | Nov 1st |
| Mount Villa | 2 | danny zucko | Oct 31st |
| Best Halloween Houses | 6 | Wil | Oct 31st |
| Boxelder bugs | 10 | ianimal | Oct 31st |
| Halloween Store, Hackettstown | 6 | K..Z. | Oct 31st |
| Hackettstown High School Sports Hall of Fame | 326 | hackypacky | Oct 26th |
| Upholsterer | 1 | Three Bees Plus | Oct 25th |
| Keys Found on Russling Road | 0 | XXX | Oct 24th |
| Knee Specialist | 9 | Lonesome Dove | Oct 22nd |
| Tailor for Men's Slacks | 3 | Mrs. Pipes | Oct 21st |
| Pig Roast | 3 | DAF | Oct 18th |
| HHS Football 2020-2023 | 308 | ianimal | Oct 17th |
| Maria Bonita - Mexican Restaurant | 185 | Jonelle | Oct 16th |
| Honda Auto body | 12 | John S. | Oct 16th |
| Rite aid closing | 37 | DH | Oct 16th |
| National Guards | 12 | Outdoors Women | Oct 15th |
| ISO machine shop | 2 | Pyc | Oct 15th |
| Cell Carrier Reccos - Verizon vs ATT | 13 | HcktwnSoccerMom | Oct 14th |
| Free Optimum mobile service to Israel | 3 | Anna R | Oct 11th |
| Husky Mix Found on Grand 10/8/23 | 1 | Local Druid | Oct 8th |
| Was there an Old Mill once on route 57 behind the storage units | 7 | Outdoors Women | Oct 8th |
| Found Tortie Kitten/Cat | 16 | Rebecca | Oct 8th |