Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

If you live in panther valley and you live in the area of mallard dr "first right after you pull in the gate" First of all I want to stress that this is very real. Not only have I seen this myself but now my wife and kids have seen this also. About 2 weeks ago I was driving around the turn on mallard and I saw a "wild cat" the size of a BIG DOG. This was the first time I have seen this cat and the tail was extremely long and it ran in front of my truck. The 2nd time I saw this cat was like 4 days later on the left back street of the golf course road. This time when I saw it it was sitting by a tree and then when I honked my horn it ran like lightning. I know what I saw and what I saw I would describe as a very dark either mountain lion or "ironically" panther looking cat. So then low and behold last night my wife and kids are walking down the same street and my ALL of my kids along with my wife ALL saw this same cat and it took off into a yard of one of our nieghbors. When they explained what it looked like it was the same exact cat that I saw, I know nothing about wild cats or lions. However Ican tell you that if you are familiar with the statue out front of the valley there is a black/dark/brown/ cat about that size around mallard drive. I called the gate and they told us to call animal control. We did to no evail... Please if you live in this area be carefull we are not trying to scare anyone just create awareness. This animal is real it is not a dog it is 100% some type of very big cat with a long tail and a very big head and it is extremey fast!

Jason Strider
Apr '11

Could be a Red Fox.

BABYBULL24 BABYBULL24
Apr '11

It would be great if next time you think to snap a picture with your cell before you honk the horn. I know there have been times when I thought after the fact that I should have thought to use my cell camera.

People with children or small pets do always need to keep an eye out for wildlife these days.


Not a fox not a dog IT is definitely a cat of some sort. Now if its a mountain cat or whatever type of cat I do not know but it is definitely a cat that is roughly I would say 145 185lbs. The reason I say its definitely a cat is because I saw the whiskers and the face and the tail and the way it ran. My wife and all of my kids saw the same exact animal 8 days after I had my 2nd sighting. I have my camera on like "ready to click" I have been driving around just trying to see if I could find it again and take a picture. But it is here and probably will be seen again..

Jason Strider
Apr '11

Omg this post really scares me!!! I live on mallard and just last night my dog was acting crazy barking at something out a back window. I dIdnt see anything but today when I was outside I saw my garbage can tipped over and everything looked like it was ravaged through and taken to a spot in the woods about 20 feet away. Thought maybe a bear but now who knows! I hope someone figures this out and I wont be taking my small dog outside at night anymore. Jason, Are you living on mallard also?

Kissycat Kissycat
Apr '11

Think the last official Mountain Lion killed in NJ was in the late 40's or early 50's but who knows. Don't think you could mistake something like this...

http://photos.nj.com/photogallery/2009/09/mountain_lion_caught_on_camera.html

BABYBULL24 BABYBULL24
Apr '11

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

What did animal control tell you when you called? They really should take care of this before someone or a family pet gets hurt. Also, did you see this at night or during the day? Could it have been a Cougar (see to the right)?

mebradar mebradar
Apr '11

I believe it, we have seen the same thing is Blairstown near my parents house!

Mommyof3 Mommyof3
Apr '11

have seen the same thing in flanders area in last few years off and on. was told it is a mountain lion and there are a pair in area and they do travel extensively....told by an animal control employee they have been spotted and nothing to fear as they are like any other wild animal and if they are behaving as they should leave them alone. I could not believe my eyes when I saw it....but know what I saw and then found out that they are in area.

wildlifespotter wildlifespotter
Apr '11

Just found this thread: http://www.hackettstownlife.com/forum/123304

With this information:

If anyone sees any big cats, they should IMMEDIATELY call:

1) NJDEP at 888-WARN-DEP, and then:
2) Mick Valent NJDEP wild/large cat expert (mostly deals with bobcats): 908.638.4127.

mebradar mebradar
Apr '11

Really - if a large wild mountian cat exists in NJ - you want to kill it?

Really - thats want you want to do?

Yeeshhh....I am no tree huggin, global warming, don't kill the bears kinda guy but if there is colony of mountain lions in NJ we need to kill them?

Hey im all for killing Deer 6 days to Sunday - 24/7 - 365 but leave them cats alone...

BABYBULL24 BABYBULL24
May '11

WTF!

If it is a Bobcat or larger he/she is surviving by avoiding man! A much bigger danger is the NW NJ White Trash that could enter your home.

Bobcats are elusive in the Catskills but they have been found. They weigh up to 40 pounds. They run from man as he has hunted them to near extinction.

iJay2 iJay2
May '11

iJay2 - way to be racist!!


What ever it is, it has to be eating something, so either the things is eating out of the trash cans or someone is feeding it. I would think if its eating small dogs or cats we would hear about a lot more missing and never found.

Just Asking Just Asking
May '11

Have you notified the PVPOA or the Crest
About this?? If it isn't a joke then that is also
Something you need to do!!

Crest resident Crest resident
May '11

My family and myself are charity type people we would NEVER want the cat killed simply relocated. I am a hunter and a fisherman myself and all of the years I have been hunting in PA and NJ and even up in maine I have never seen a cat like this live in front of my face. The trash is probably our local bear if you live on mallard. I call the bear charlie he is about 350lbs and completely harmless as long as you keep your distance and yell he will simply run away "he is in my yard almost daily". I am used to bears and know all of the things there is to know about them "again I am a local hunter". I actually do not hunt bears, mainly because I do not eat them. I only hunt stuff that we eat as should any hunter. I have tried the animal control several times and just get a answering machine... lol (I guess they only control from mon-fri). We spoke to another nieghbor that we saw at shoprite yesterday and she confirmed she has see the cat as well. Here are the facts so that from this post on we do not get things confused.

There is a BIG cat hanging out in and or around the entire length of mallard drive in panther valley. (this is NOT a UFO sighting! This is NOT a ghost sighting!) This is a family of children yelling and screaming and running home at top speed because of seeing a live animal that they never saw live in the wild before! All of my sons have been hunting with me, fishing, they all have cleaned animals to put on our table! They were scared sh..less!

There is no answer at animal control

I am guessing when I say (there is no animal control within panther valley?) WHY NOT?

Last but not least and I stress please just be carefull I have kids and even if I didn't I care for other people so we are telling ya to just be carefull. Monday morning we will try the animal control again.

Jason Strider
May '11

I've given this post a lot of thought since reading it late last night. I have lived in PV for almost 4 years. There is a 3-legged doe that hobbles around in the Mountainside section of PV since as long as I have been here, if not long(?). IF this was a mountain lion/cougar/panther, I think she would be easy prey. A large cat would need LARGE amounts of food, not just picking trough someone's garbage. I really wonder what it is that you saw. I also think someone, somewhere would see the remains of whatever it is killing. Just my thoughts.

Jackie Jackie
May '11

Very True! My wife went to the house where her and my children saw the cat just to inform the owners of the sighting. I didn't just see it 2 times myself but my family saw it also and now we come to find out so did like 3 other homes in the area..it has to be eating something..

Jason Strider
May '11

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

Jason is the Manimal in PV trying to cover up his mutant transformations into a panther. Or it's just all the divorced cougars sniffing out the young landscapers on the golf course. I'm going with option 2.

Manimal - 1983
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6iQ-mzYRl3s

Reggie Reggie
May '11

Good call Reggie!

Calico696 Calico696
May '11

Anyone know how Panther Valley got it's name? Any chance there have been cougars previously in the area?

justintime justintime
May '11

"According to the sale agreement, the developer could not use the name 'Panther Lodge' or 'Stagmont.' Instead, the developer called the proposed community 'Panther Valley.' Panther Ledge is an old local name dating to the days when panthers inhabited the area, and in 1805 Warren County marked the final passing of the panther on a ledge in what is now known as Panther Valley."

http://www.ourpanthervalley.com/history/

Reggie Reggie
May '11

I am a total animal lover myself and would not propose we just kill it - as Jason himself has said- but it is good to be warned. I would think small animals (cats) would be in danger? And of course there have been people attacked out west my mountain lions. I wonder what provokes them to attack humans? I would love to see a picture! Aren't mountain lions usually out around dusk? Is that when you saw it Jason? Out west where my cousin lives, there are mountain lions all over.........there is no such thing as stray cats.......they don't survive. Her husband was surrounded one day walking his dog by more than one mountain lion and he had to pick up his dog and kick at them to get them to leave............they obviously were after his dog, not him, he said. Can be scary!

Hastings Resident Hastings Resident
May '11

Justintime - I found the below at http://pvpoa.com/pvpoa.asp?CategoryName=history

When panthers boldly roamed the hills and valleys of Allamuchy territory, their home was the tree, the hollow, the cave, the ledge. Moving silently, scarely displacing a twig, these great cats, although predators, were never known to attack man - even for survival.

As a consequence of their habitat, athwart the rugged mountain terrain of the Allamuchy Range, many local designations are testimony to their past presence: Panther Rock, Panther Hollow, Panther Ledge, Panther Creek, Panther Run. Ancient records indicate that bounties were paid in New Jersey of 20 shillings to Christians, 10 shillings to Indians for panther hides, and 5 shillings for whelps.

Panthers migrated westward as the competition with man for available food became desperate and was greatly accelerated by the slaughter of deer by the settler (either for food or for hides). The vanishing point for these great beasts reached the critial point in the late 1700s and early 1800s.

County records reveal that New Jersey's last big cat met his end in 1805 in a thicket behind Panther Ledge...the high promontory overlooking the 5th hole of the Panther Valley Golf Course.

The princely cat is dead...but history has enshrined him for all time. He lives in the beauty and breathtaking grandeur of Panther Valley.
An excerpt from "The History of Panther Valley - Allamuchy, New Jersey" by Jo Librizzi

The complete 38 page History of Panther Valley was presented to each new resident as part of the Welcome Packet. The Communication Committee believes that it is very important for residents to know about the place in which they live. Additional copies may be purchased at the PVPOA office for $5.00 each to cover additional publishing costs.

Reggie Reggie
May '11

Jason,

I absolutely believe you saw a mountain lion, and this is **not** the first time I hear of a sighting of one right in the Panther Valley area. There were other reports of sightings in Panther Valley months ago, very possibly the same cat.

You are definitely doing the right thing by giving people the heads-up.

What time of day did you see the animal? I am a photographer with a long lens, and would love to get a shot, if only so that NJ DEP can stop denying their existence in our State! :-)

Rebecka Rebecka
May '11

We were at a friends house last night in Panther Valley and everyone was talking about the siting. SO they are all heading the warning.

Christine Christine
May '11

I do not doubt that a wild animal of some sort was seen, however, in my 30 years of living in Panther Valley, playing in the woods as a kid, etc. I have never seen anything remotely resembling a wild cat. Bears, deer, the occasional stray dog? Sure.

Again, I'm not trying to call anyone a liar here, but until someone can produce a photo of this creature that everyone claims to have seen on multiple occasions I'll hold on to some shred of calm. What is this thing bigfoot? In an age where nearly every cell phone in America has a camera on it, no one can manage to catch a shot? That's one elusive animal.

Take it for what it's worth. If someone can produce a photo of this thing it will be interesting to say the least. I wonder what the thing has been living on, I've seen the trash that people put out for pickup, not that healthy :-).

Lifetime Resident Lifetime Resident
May '11

Ironically I saw it 2 times at the same time around 6:30pm and then just the other day my wife and kids were out there and they saw it around the same time, just further down the road. I saw the cat by the back road of the golf course swim club and my wfe and kids saw it up the road if you go up around the bend to the left about 200 feet past where the overlook is on the right hand side it was near the bush of that 2nd house on the corner. I just called Mick Valent he deals with bobcats (908-638-4127) so we will see if he can maybe come out. If it was a bobcat then it is a very big bobcat. It was bigger than my dog "lab". I am going to drive down there today and look around with my camera. There has to be a reason we have seen this cat on the same road now 3 times over a few weeks. Needless to say My wife and kids wont walk at night anymore lol the kids got quite the shock on their run home night of...

Jason Strider
May '11

It is a Fisher Cat. Not really a cat. Part of the Weasel family. They are not agressive animals. It was probably pushed out of it's den by some new construction in the area.

elmax elmax
May '11

a Fisher Cat is not bigger than a lab............

Hastings Resident Hastings Resident
May '11

Surely this must be the cat you saw..

http://www.hackettstownlife.com/forum/287203

redneck redneck
May '11

okay i need to chime in. remember the path through the old construction site (now the new development) that led to "the cliff"? When i was a kid (32 now) i was walking through the woods and came across TWO of these animals. They appeared to be adolescent but they chased me down the mountain and i wound up bruised and bloody in the abandoned baseball field. I'm literally terrified of the woods to this day. Those cats are up there.

Chucky Chucky
May '11

Oh and it's also worth mentioning that all the new construction up there has displaced so much wildlife that i GUARANTEE more sitings.

Chucky Chucky
May '11

or sightings. whichever.

Chucky Chucky
May '11

Hmmmmm. Maybe this explains all the missing dogs and cats.







Just kidding.

collegeviewrider collegeviewrider
May '11

Ok so we asked around and more people have seen this cat I will be trying to get in on camera and post the video if possible

Jason Strider
May '11

Wow this is really interesting and scary at the same time! I hope someone gets a picture soon. If it is a Mountain Lion or something close to that why wouldn't it attack man? I have seen several shows on t.v. of attacks by these "cats" out west. This is definitely something to be concerned about.


Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

Here are two "cubs" sleeping! Where can I claim my prize for this "breaking news" photo!

John C John C
May '11

Jason, anyone other than you or your family see this big cat? Could it be a 40-45 pound Bobcat?


The one thing that I noticed from the original description is how dark it is. If it can be described as black or really dark brown, then it's no bobcat, mountain lion or coyote. They're like mebradar's picture and are definitely a tan color. The fisher would be the right color, even if those are more northerly they've supposedly been making their way south through the Adirondacks to Catskills to north NJ like some other animals have. If dark, and bigger than a lab, it's too big for any of those and with the dark color could well be a bear cub. It's just so hard to tell without a picture.


Redneck,

That photo has gone around for years. It actually was taken in the west somewhere.

Spring Fever
May '11

Wait, what? I thought the only thing that Redneck posted was a link to another thread about a missing black and white cat... Am I missing something here?

Heather Heather
May '11

Heather - I believe Spring meant to refer to BABYBULL's post not redneck's.

Calico696 Calico696
May '11

All I'm saying is I was twelve when those things came after me and I'm 32 now. They've been up there forever and are being displaced by all the new construction.

Heather, Ash says he misses you.

chucky chucky
May '11

Ah, I see now Calico, thanks for clearig that up for me lol.

Chucky-- Asher!!! Give him a billion kisses for me, and BTW... You never told me this about the PV woods! Oh man I can't wait til I see you guys next lol

Heather Heather
May '11

I'll tell you all about it next time we hang out.

chucky chucky
May '11

Thanks Calico, it was Babybull's picture...not Redneck's.

Spring Fever
May '11

Chucky, you were really chased by squirrels. Next time don't smoke a bong up there. LOL...

Seriously though... I have hunted these woods in Warren, Sussex, and Morris counties and never seen a mountain lion in my 20 years of doing so. You also don't hear about other hunters seeing them either. With all the hunters who are in the woods during buck season and pheasant season, it is impossible for no one to ever see one. I've had a person in my hunting party chased by a bear in the past. So if mountain lions were out there, people would have seen them. You are either seeing a coyote, bobcat, or fox.

Metsman Metsman
May '11

Bobcat maybe, but please don't suggest that i would mistake a coyote or fox for a large cat. I was twelve. not blind. How about we have a HL hiking trip up there and whoever doesn't get chased out of the woods wins the discussion.

Chucky Chucky
May '11

Does anyone have a tree cam / trail cam? I have an infrared one for nighttime shots, but I've temporarily lent it to my brother... we really need to place a few of these around the area the animal was seen.

Calling all trail cams!

Rebecka Rebecka
May '11

Has anyone bothered to notify the PVPOA or The Crest?? I think that is very important. This is very scary especially for those with children. Mr. Strider is that your real name you are using? There is no listing of anyone with that last name in the 2011 Panther Valley directory.

Crest resident Crest resident
May '11

I found this on the NJ Fish and Game site

"Bobcat Information

The bobcat is an elusive creature found in the northern hardwood forests of New Jersey. Bobcat declined in the 1800s as forests were cleared for lumber, fuel and agriculture, and by the early 1970s they were thought to be extirpated (locally extinct) from the state. Between 1978 and 1982 the Division conducted a restoration project through which 24 bobcats were trapped in Maine and released in northern NJ.

Today bobcat, though classified as endangered, appear to be fairly well-established in the northern hardwood forests of the state, perhaps even more widespread than many think. Their elusive nature makes them a challenge to study."

Nosila Nosila
May '11

Awesome, I want to see it! lmao

Pepper Cat Pepper Cat
May '11

Jason, you saw nothing larger than this:

http://catskillmountaineer.com/animals-bobcats.html


Maybe it was a chupacabra

chupacabra
May '11

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

They are vicious

chupacabra
May '11

Yup the crest was notified My wife went there and spoke to them and also the ppvoa along with the security "3 times". The reason why I haven't posted is because I give up!! Nothing is going to be done and we are just convinced of this fact! So all I can do is protect my own family and not have them do their walk when they normally do at night. It was not a bobcat "I have seen them before. So anyway good luck I am 100% fed up with no response. How ironic is it that several residents have seen the same thing, not to mention there is a guy who has lived here for 32 years and lives about 10 minutes from us and has a mountain lion on his property and this guy has pictures, videos, and lots of guns that he uses to shoot in the air to scare it. It is just very depressing that all we see now is the security guard driving up and down the road every night at the same time in the area we saw it. I have no idea what thats gonna do but whatever...... Be safe

Jason Strider
May '11

Jason- It's very funny you mention this large animal. Late last year- perhaps it was November- my husband was walking our dog in our development. We live in the Mountain Ridge development of PV. He came back stunned and said that he was walking on Mallard (which is the entry road into MR that will one day be connect to the Mallard at the front of the gate) and all of a sudden our dog froze and started to quiver. He looked up and there was this huge cat-like animal crouched down watching them. It was on the woodsy side of Mallard where they haven't moved many trees with the construction. He said it was huge and he's never ever seen an animal like it before. I asked him.. Are you sure it wasn't a deer or something? and he said it was MUCH bigger than a deer would have been in the position. Our dog goes nuts w/ deer... and she was petrified. He said he just started walking backwards until it was out of site and went right home.

katievits24 katievits24
May '11

Jason, there are lots of people who won't believe what you saw. Many people have seen and reported sightings of large cat type animals all over Warren County and parts of Morris County for 50 years or more. Many of them are hunters and people who live
bordering large wooded areas and know what they are seeing and hearing. It's been common knowledge for decades. I wouldn't be surprised in the least to find out there are mountain lions alive and well living in Warren County. Welcome to the neighborhood. Just do be careful.

Spring Fever
May '11

Lets see......lots of pictures (can we see them), videos (can we watch them?) shooting guns in the air (in Alamuchy Twp....I know a few "Staties" that would be interested in that) Lets see the evidence. You state that alot of people have seen this, but they are strangely silent. Very strange indeed. Guess you want to see your name in Weird NJ.

John C John C
May '11

This is just rediculous the way everyone is acting on this thread. Obviously "it" hasn't bothered a soul to this date. Nobody can post a pic of it and supposedly they got so close to this thing that they was able to beep the horn loudly and it ran off then.
Like one person mentioned "why didn't you take a pic and post it?"

If something like this does exist and its not bothering anyone then.....SO WHAt, let the poor animal be left alone for god sakes. Just don't get dumn and start trying to feed the thing!

Hey maybe its the "NJ DEVIL" lol....

OptimusPrime OptimusPrime
May '11

Does some one REALLY need to explain the law of gravity to your neighbor? Really?

Ryan (ligitty) Ryan (ligitty)
May '11

"You state that a lot of people have seen this, but they are strangley silent."

I didn't read all the posts, but if someone said people are silent on the topic, that's not
true and they never have been silent on the topic, at least not for 50+ years that
I have lived in and around the area and close to large wooded areas.

In all probability, the people who have lived in the area for any length of time don't give a second thought to the possibility that there are at least a few large cats type animals
living in and around Warren County. It's not new 'news' anymore, but it obviously is to JS in that he seems to be surprised and alarmed at his sighting some kind of a large cat or bear, so near his home. As with anyone who lives near or borders a woods, a little extra caution for nature's animals is expected and normal. Just don't encourage their fondness for your property by putting out food or trying to tame them.

No one is trying to make this into a Jersey Devil thing or a Big Foot sighting. It's just a
big furry animal for goodness sake! But still, if I were JS, I would take a few extra precautions for where and when I walked. That's all...

Spring Fever
May '11

i believe the people that say they saw the cat , animals are good at hiding if they dont want to be seen , how can you say the last cat is dead , did they walk the woods inch by inch , in 2011 we are STILL finding new species on this earth .

cowgirl1 cowgirl1
May '11

On Friday afternoon my co-worker saw a mountain lion walk through the parking lot. He said he was positive and brought up images of wild cats online just to make sure. The company is in Sparta, on the Lafayette border. He saw all the features, long tail, tan coloring etc. He thinks it was a cub and came inside in case mom was around.


Now that, even I, find hard to believe!?! Sounds like "A Jo ke"?

Spring Fever
May '11

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

I caught him and put him to good use!

Cougar Lover
May '11

That was unnecessary spring fever. I have been lurking on this forum for apprx 2 years. I read both threads about mountain lions and posted my story since it just happened last week. No need to call me a joke. Word spread through the office and I went to ask him because of the stories I've been reading here. He googled several photos and said that he was sure it was a mountain lion. If u don't believe it, fine. Lots of people are sharing stories, why is mine funny to you?


Can't speak for PV, but if a mountain lion is seen Flanders, please call Mt. Olive Animal Control. I've only had 2 instances to contact them(about 2 yrs. ago) but the officer was accommodating and responded to my questions. I believe his name was Officer Cirone, but I don't know if he he still the AC officer.

Lilac
May '11

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service concludes eastern cougar extinct
http://www.fws.gov/northeast/ecougar/newsreleasefinal.html

Map from 1935 to 2000 documented existance
http://eprn.homestead.com/eprn_001.jpg

NJ says "The puma is not on the State endangered species list and is considered extirpated."
http://www.fws.gov/northeast/ecougar/pdf/Easterncougar5-yearreview-final-111610.pdf page 19


I just don't get how a "ghost hunter" is skeptical regarding wildlife.

Chucky Chucky
May '11

I saw a big cat outside my door six months ago. It was 4 am and I called Tim Norton, the animal control officer. It was big and scary. He said it was probably a Bobcat and went back to sleep.

I looked it up and they have been slowly repopulating Bobcats in New Jersey since around 1980. Here is one link:

http://www.defenders.org/programs_and_policy/wildlife_conservation/solutions/species_restoration_projects/new_jersey_bobcats.php

Erik B. Anderson Erik B. Anderson
May '11

A Jo, I too, have been on the forum for a few years and have learned to be skeptical in the accuracy of some posts and responders on this site. If I misjudged your story, I am sorry.

However, it would be most unusual for a mountain lion to do as your friend stated, although stranger things have happened. I will check out some newspapers to see if it was reported since it would certainly be news worthy and if true, should be made public for safety reasons.

For the record, we have a responder or two who is famous for popping up with a new 'name'
especially when attempting to stir the pot or just bored with life. Your name is what prompted me to conclude it was one of the HF neighborhood trolls. No offense was intended.

If this made the local news, please let us know the site.

Spring Fever
May '11

I am not quite sure why some people are so upset on the forum.. all Jason was trying to do was warn people about the animal.. I don't know why people don't believe him or why it's even an issue. I didn't get the impression that Jason (or anybody else) was saying this animal should be put down or shot at ... I mean, it was a warning! As my husband has seen it in PV too... I don't see the harm in a warning for all the neighbors... just be a little extra aware of your surroundings. We are in their backyard afterall!

katievits24 katievits24
May '11

I'm skeptical abouts ghosts also Chucky! As with ghosts, I want to see the proof! Now, are you real Chucky? Show me a photo as proof, or do you dare come to a HL Happy Hour.

John C John C
May '11

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

I waited out back with a mask on...is this it? ;)

INeedMoreCowBell INeedMoreCowBell
May '11

katievits - you hit the nail on the head with your post!!

Rebecka Rebecka
May '11

Thanks Rebecka!!! :)

katievits24 katievits24
May '11

Nah, INMCB, the one I saw was definitely darker than that. Nice mask though. ;-)

Aquarius Aquarius
May '11

hahaha Cowbell this is the second forum I've seen that photo in the last week or so


There were mountain lions released in the Johnsonburg/blairstown area a few years ago to control unwanted wildlife population.

TanyaNJ TanyaNJ
May '11

Does ANYONE have a tree / trail cam???? It's all we need.

Rebecka Rebecka
May '11

Tanya, What is your source for this information?
Thanks...

Spring Fever
May '11

Tanya, how do you know that? Until there's some kind of scientific evidence or photographic evidence, it is nothing but mistaken identity. Look at how many bigfoot sightings there are across the country, yet there's never any real concrete evidence to back up the claims. Bobcats can grow up to 2 feet in height. To some people that is probably huge.

Metsman Metsman
May '11

Spring Fever, my co-worker's sighting was not reported. Throughout our office, most people doubted him. But he was adament about what he saw and it was daylight so he said it was very visible. The mountain lion came out of some woods, walked through our parking lot past a trailer that had a grill, and back into a swampy woods area. We had just had a BBQ 2 hours before. So maybe he smelled it and that's why he came out. I don't see what the big deal is. It's not like we are talking about the Abominable snowman. Mountain lions exist. Do they live in our area? Who knows. But it wouldn't be impossible.


Regarding Bobcats, are they all spotted with a short tail? Most of my company thinks that is what he saw. He is insisting it was tan, no spots, with a long tail. I googled bobcats and I didn't see any that resemble a mountion lion.


Oh and people have seen Mountain Lions for 50 years around here! LOL... That is silly. Someone would have killed one by now or taken a picture if that were the case. My dad worked for the division of Fish and Game for 20 years and was always out on wildlife management properties posting signs and stocking birds and mowing fields, yet never saw mountain lions. Believe me, people are seeing bobcats. With the amount of deer we have in NJ, there would be evidence from deer carcasses of mountain lions.

Metsman Metsman
May '11

Saw my brother last weekend he said last summer while riding his Harley he came upon a dead Bobcat on the side of the road hit by a car along 517 in front of Pub 517 so I guess they are around.

babybull24 babybull24
May '11

I just have to say I totally believe this guy saw this cat type creature, I remember living in Allamuchy when I was very little, and people talking about a black bear sighting, and no one really believed it. and now... they are all over the place. Including my front door, and the odd thing about that... is I live in Phillipsburg two blocks off of Rt 22.. So if I can have a black bear at my front door, I'm sure its possible that there is a Mt Lion hanging around too. And I'm sure if there hadn't been pictures in the paper about the bear at my door, no one would have believed it. I know I would sure love to see a pic of the cat... hell I wouldn't mind seeing it, but not close up...

Cheryl71 Cheryl71
May '11

Cheryl71, the difference is black bear were never extinct in NJ. They have always been around, they were just an endangered species for a long time. They were protected so that their numbers could increase. There hasn't been a population of mountain lions here since the early 1800's.

Metsman Metsman
May '11

Metsman - Not only is the eastern cougar/mountain lion extinct, but a western one's habitat reaches only as far as Michigan and Illinois even with new movement eastward. That's a long way off particularly considering a bobcat's territory is very close. They didn't used to think they were in NJ, but as Erik pointed out that's changing. That's exactly the kind of case that Cheryl is talking about where animals close by are moving in. (just like the coyotes have done) And others have pointed out the evidence of it.

I was just searching for some pictures to show the difference between a mountain lion and a bobcat, and I found something interesting in the wikipedia entry:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bobcat


It talks about the existence of a "melanistic" mutation that's been observed in Florida. It's a gene than can turn the animal's fur completely black or black with some spotting. A bobcat like that is a much more likely explanation of what Jason saw. That would be in territory these days, and explain a dark color. Either that or just for what ever reason under what ever lighting it appeared darker than you would expect a bobcat to be.


Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

Watch Out!!!!

iJay3 iJay3
May '11

GC, there's lack of physical evidence. No tracks, feces, carcasses or bones, photographs, animal carcasses they may have preyed on, etc. It's possible they can move east, but why haven't there been any confirmed populations in PA or NY? They would have to settle there before coming to us. I think it's easier to believe people are mistaking a 50 pound bobcat for a mountain lion. The average mountain lion is 80-100 pounds. Also, sometimes when you look at something from a distance, your eyes can play tricks on you and you may think something is bigger than what it really is. I know that has happened to me when I try to judge the size of a deer.

Metsman Metsman
May '11

Metsman - I agree. That's what I said. ;-)


Oh, I wasn't sure GC. LOL...

Metsman Metsman
May '11

I live at the bottom Kings Highway way back in the woods, and I have seen the same thing big cat, long tail, tan in color. My neighbor has an Alpaca Farm in the same area, he too has seen it!


A few years ago I took my kids to Stephens State park to the playground in the campground area. My kids were small at the time 3-8 yrs old. It was about this time of year. We still needed sweatshirts.

We were playing for a little while when the ranger drove over to us. She told me to keep an eye out because they had a Mt. Lion coming down to the river through the camp campground, and to keep the kids in sight. We packed up and headed home. Talking to some people afterwards I was told the cat was also sighted near the condos on Bilby road.

Also when I was growing up we had a family friend who was a park ranger at the Water Gap, they lived in a beautiful stone home in the woods near the river. He warned us many times to be careful because of cat sightings.

Nutmeg
May '11

I lost my pic-i-nic basket there. All I heard was "hey boo boo..." and it was gone.

mistergoogle mistergoogle
May '11

Cmon people... where are all the dead livestock or pets? If people have been seeing mountain lions for years, there would be a substantial population by now. We're not talking about a timid creature here. This is an animal that can take down an elk!

Metsman Metsman
May '11

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

yeah that may be true about what you saw , but bobcats have very short or 'bobbed' tails.

see pic

BrotherDog BrotherDog
May '11

Metsman-

Why would they kill livestock and pets when there are plenty of deer in the area, or don't you believe they are in the area either?

http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/story?id=2700121&page=1

Nutmeg
May '11

A wild mountain lion is unlikely. If Jason actually saw one, I would be more suspicious of that it was an escaped pet. Remember a few years ago a Tiger was shot in Jackson. It is entirely possible that some lunatic has a pet lion, or mountain lion, or jaguar or other large cat (s) as a pet and one escaped or got loose.

As to a wild population, I doubt it. Sorry unless I would need to see a photo and have hard forensic evidence to believe it. I've seen too many people mis identify wild animals to believe a random post on an internet forum.

Agust K. G. Agust K. G.
May '11

Nutmeg, deer run extremely fast. What's easier to kill... sheep and chickens or a deer running 40-50mph? I'd say the answer is obvious. Out west there is a big problem with mountain lions attacking livestock. Why would it be different here? Like Agust said, there have been cases where people have let pets go because they couldn't handle them anymore. One such case is a juvenile mountain lion shot in upstate NY in the early 90's. It was traced to species found in South America. It was ruled out as a pet. The article you posted Nutmeg, is from a sighting in Roxbury in 2006. The woods it was supposedly seen in, I have hunted for 15 years and have been all over the property. There are no lions up there, just a bunch of coyotes, fox, a few bear, and maybe the rare bobcat.

Metsman Metsman
May '11

Cats are extremely opportunistic and they willl take what is easy. No way livestock wouldn't be killed if there was any kind of population of mountain lions in the area.

Also if they were taking deer, they don't eat every single morsel of the animal and a cat kill is very distinctive. Hunters would run across the carcasses on a regular basis.

I watched a MonsterQuest episode once on big cat sightings in the South. They ran footage of what looked like a tremendous (like six foot long) dark cat walking along a perimeter of a field at a distance. I was like "well, that's it, that's evidence right there on film." But when they analyzed the footage using size markers (the height of a rock in the footage, the distance between two trees in the background, etc), it turned out the huge cat was really just a largish house cat of about twenty-eight inches in length. It's amazing how badly humans judge size at a distance. It's especially bad when a person thinks they see a specific something; our minds fill in all the details to match our idea.

Aquarius Aquarius
May '11

As far as bones go- there are many bones in our development. It's kind of gross actually. My dog is always sniffing them out. They are chicken bones or something like it. And again, my husband has seen this animal.

katievits24 katievits24
May '11

Cmon, if you had a mountain lion prowling your development then there would be tracks. Next time take a picture. People keep saying they've seen one, well take a picture with your phone. Guarenteed it isn't one.

Metsman Metsman
May '11

I dont know what it is, nor have I made any conclusions saying "It's definitely a _____". All I know is my husband saw a large cat-like animal while walking our dog. As he was walking our dog he didn't have a phone on him... and this was a while ago. Late last year. If we see it we definitely will take a picture!

katievits24 katievits24
May '11

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

There are bobcats (and bear, and deer, and hawks, and eagles, and....) where I work. I saw a bobcat last year run across road. I was able to pull over and observe him for a few moments before he ran off into the woods. It was the first and only time I have seen this type of animal and it was spectacular! The bobcat in this photo was photographed also where I work - the bobcat found its way into a trap for a raccoon! He was then tranquilized and fitted with a color, and released.

dragonfly dragonfly
May '11

It's probably just some pervert in a Snagglepuss costume... Heavens to Murgatroyd, exit stage left (-;

iPhone-imal iPhone-imal
May '11

dragonfly - Nice!

ian - Don't you have some Laff-A-Lympics to host??


You looking to get the gang back together Muttley?

(-;

iPhone-imal iPhone-imal
May '11

JC, when's the last time two ghosts physically came after you? I was chased off that mountain by cats the size of dogs. I get the feeling you've never been chased by a ghost. I ran down a mountain and came out bleeding at the bottom. Did you have ghosts chase you and you comically ran in place with Scooby Doo next to you?

Let's get out of here Scoob!!

Honestly- when i become a professional ghost hunter I'll comment on ghost threads. When you become a game warden you can provide your professional opinion in wildlife threads. Deal?

Chucky Chucky
May '11

Acid back in the old days made people see....and run from things that really were not there. Bet you ran from some Maine Coon Cat in heat. They do run quite large in fact. And once they start in, well, just let them finish if you know what I mean!
Did I run from anything paranormal? Cant say I ever have. Was I startled by what may be paranormal? Many times! Do I keep looking? Of course. And Chucky, you should have a college education to become a paranormal investigator, mine is actually Forest Management (BA) and Forestry and Law Enforcement (Wow....I could be a game warden if I wanted to but doesn't pay crap!) I also studied Paranormal Behavior in school,(still ongoing) but pays the bills!
But once you graduate from High School Chucky, stick with education and get your college deploma! But stay away from the drugs.....them big cats can look real nasty!

John C John C
May '11

ian - Rasafrassin sauerkraut!!!


Sounds good with hot dogs GC!

John C John C
May '11

Chucky, bobcats have been shot at 50 pounds. That would make it as big as a lot of dogs. Personally I think you were smoking some good stuff that day. LOL...

Metsman Metsman
May '11

Metsman
I have not seen them myself. But do not doubt what I have been told. I do not hunt so I really have never paid attention to tracks. I will start to keep on eye out. Though I can't say if I saw a cat that I would grab my camera. (I would be scared.)

If the livestock are so easy to prey on why aren't the coyotes an issue? I have seen a pack of six kill a deer. (Harriman Sate Park Oct. 2009) Not so long ago people were denying coyotes were in the area. (yes, I know they were re-introduced to control the deer population)

I know a house on Spring Lane that used to keep a few sheep (5 years ago?) and with in two weeks each sheep disappeared. The fence was pushed down and the one by one were gone. Always dismissed it as a bear, but who knows?

I do not think there is a population boom of big cats, I just am not dismissing the idea just because I myself have not seen one. Does anyone know some one that lives in the condos on Bilby Rd? I know there was a cat issue a few years ago. Maybe they remember more details.

Aquaris-
A cat would not completely clean a kill but the foxes, coyotes and buzzards would certainly finish the job for them. There are carcasses all over the woods.

Nutmeg
May '11

We know there are coyotes here because there is clear evidence pointing to such. There was a woman who was attacked by a coyote last year in New Brunswick. So I'm sure there are cases where pets and livestock have been killed as well. I've also seen carcasses in the woods and on the side of the road. My father also shot one once.

It's not impossible that big cats could be here, but... Why is it every time they investigate a sighting, there is never any evidence? The same is true in NY and PA. They investigate sightings and do not find the proof that is necessary to say that there is a mountain lion population. How can a 100+ pound animal not leave behind any evidence?

Metsman Metsman
May '11

"How can a 100+ pound animal not leave behind any evidence?"

Kind of like Bigfoot, there's never any evidence there either. ;-)

Calico696 Calico696
May '11

Or leprachauns... lol

Metsman Metsman
May '11

Well, I actually did see a leprechaun with me own eyes once. Then again maybe not, it was a long pub crawl last St. Paddy's Day. :)

Seriously though, I agree with you about the no evidence thing Metsman. Somebody would have found something by now. Bones, prints, scat, carcass, etc.

I have seen coyotes with my own eyes as well as scat in the woods. We actually have quite a few near where I live. No evidence of mountain lions though.

Calico696 Calico696
May '11

In the news tonight:
Mountain Lions confirmed in Conneticut (previously believed extinct in the East Coast)
Confirmation by shape & size of paw prints found.

happy girl
Jun '11

Is it a breeding population or one? Could be one someone let go.

Metsman Metsman
Jun '11

Just read the article. They believe it is one someone let go.

Metsman Metsman
Jun '11

On my way to work this morning I passed what appeared to be a large dead cat on the eastbound side of Route 46 just west of Villa Venice. Restaurant. I'll check on my way home but this was no housecat!

Lady Jayne Lady Jayne
Oct '11

Could be a bobcat. Mountain lions are the size of a large dog.

Metsman Metsman
Oct '11

my son told me that a few weeks ago that a woman saw what looked like a bobcat crossing bald eagle and it ran into the woods.it was day time and she said it was no dog or fox.scary

luvjaz luvjaz
Oct '11

I have seen a bobcat by the auction on Stiger St, in the early morning hours. It walked up the railing where the cattle enter. Not a large animal but powerful looking and I loved the fluff coming out of its ears.

midnightgardener1 midnightgardener1
Oct '11

i can't believe i forgot to mention this as well.my husband was going to work around 4:00 a.m and said he saw what looked like a large biege cat run into the woods. he said no way in heck was it a deer or fox. this was last month around bald eagle.

luvjaz luvjaz
Oct '11

there was a mountain lion hit by a car in connecticut a few years ago it was tracked back to south dakota so to think that was the only animal to roam this far east is plain stupid there were no bears to b seen years ago yet in 30 years we now have to hunt them there r now porcupine and fisher cats yet no one sees them we have thousands of mink otter beaver bobcat coyote yet most people never see them so clearly the mountain lion can be out back and u might never see them one will get caught on film somewhere in nj and then u na sayers will eat crow . dont tell me the crows r gone 2

hambone bob
Dec '12

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

check it out got this on film today in area. Mt Olive

muteman muteman
May '13

and I had it verified with PD who came up behind me. I really think a mt lion because has tail and very muscular submitted to NJ Fish and game.

muteman muteman
May '13

Muteman - was picture taken in International Trade zone area or closure to Hackettstown?

Yelena Yelena
May '13

correct have a couple more but this one you can see muscularity and tail. Really surprised me as I thought they were all west of mississippi.

muteman muteman
May '13

Funny I lived in Mt Olive for a couple of years and I thought I heard what could be a mountain lion, but everyone thought it was completely impossible.

luvjaz luvjaz
May '13

I saw this "cat" once many years ago (at least 15) when I lived in Village Green apartment complex and took a walk near their basketball field by water supply. I used to live on other corner of the village near woods and stream but never saw it by us.

Yelena Yelena
May '13

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

I am no hunter and have not seen in wild before but def had long tail with black at the end and the first glance was the rear view and what stuck out was the light colored fur. I assumed it was a deer but then it profiled and was def a large cat with long tail. It kneeled down twice like a cat would to urinate or deficate. This pic also shows the tail if you blow it up. I will also say I did not believe these cat were out here because all the Div of WIldlife info has them extinct out this way.

muteman muteman
May '13

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

another pic. funny I said wild and was referring to NJ in post before.

muteman muteman
May '13

muteman, You need to change Date and Time setting on your Nikon CoolPix S4000 camera. It shows you took these pictures on 3/31/2013 on 9:29 PM

newbee newbee
May '13

newbee, how does one correct that? I have the same problem with my land line phone recordings. Recorded messages and times are days off and no one I've asked, can correct it. No need for details here, but could you list just an on line source to correct issue? Muteman may be able to use same source to correct his camera issue...

Great pics, Muteman.

Hopefully an article on this sighting will make the papers in the not too distant future.

Spring Fever
May '13

Wifey's work camera don't play with it. Only had it as she is a realtor and carries it with her

muteman muteman
May '13

Ok that picture is clearly a deer. Look at the snout on the second image. You can clearly see it in the shadow. Plus its stand to tall and straight up. Its a deer.
People are seeing either coyotes or bobcats. Things always appear larger when caught off guard, running or from a distance. Besides these things are so elusive that to see it more then once in a few weeks, does not happen. People out in Mt lion country dont even see them that much if ever. I see Bobcats running across the road from time to time and they always catch me off guard and appear larger.
If Mt lions were around why dont we see scat or tracks in the snow. Im in the woods 7 days a week and I dont see any signs.

Smokey
May '13

It's legs look a little too meaty to be a deer.

I would have guessed a Bobcat because I'm not seeing the long tail, but I wasn't there so will go with whatever Muteman and the police say they saw. It certainly is possible it was a mountain lion. They are in and out of NJ periodically.

Spring Fever
May '13

guarantee not a deer that is Jersey's rodent I have seen them everywhere and all the time even plowed a few with my truck, look at first picture posted can clearly see elongated tail. IDK if you can blow up these pictures but on original pics I can and absolutely not a deer. Def a feline of some sort not sure what type. The other two people with me also do not think it was not a deer.

muteman muteman
May '13

One pic looks like a deer, but the other one does not. Hard to tell. Scary thought if it's something else.

botheredbyu botheredbyu
May '13

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

Well, these are interesting photos, certainly. I would like to know exactly where this is (where the cat is walking) if you could tell us that, muteman?

The animal in the images is clearly NOT a deer. For reference, see the attached image of a deer walking, Smokey, and compare the position of her legs to the position of the animal's legs in photo one. No one with any outdoor experience could confuse the photographed animal with a deer.

My question is - were these images actually taken in the location stated? If you tell us where you were when you took the pics, muteman, then we could verify that these aren't simply images you may have taken off the Internet. :-) With that verified, I think we may have the best proof ever that there are mountain lions in NJ.

Rebecka Rebecka
May '13

I doubt muteman is lying. Why would he?

botheredbyu botheredbyu
May '13

I saw one just like that is hope more than once,I am sure he saw it,but everyone mocked my post.

Red Dog
May '13

The first picture, using the zoom on my computer, appears to show the cat carrying something in it's mouth. Does anyone else have a clear picture of # 1?

Spring Fever
May '13

sorry,in Hope nj

Red Dog
May '13

2011 end of summer, had few cops and animal control come to near my house on east ave, there was a 150-200 lb mountain lion literally sunbathing next to the river, they tranquilized and removed him, scared the sh!t out of me, i was walking cemetery path and he just lifted his head and looked at me, i was maybe 30 feet away i just backed away and called the cops.


big cats are in new jersey.. be careful

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4kalaFCOqzA

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQn2Sf4aWf8

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_M3GKFTSKI


It's a coyote I've seen enough of them in my lifetime it's not even in the feline family

oldred
May '13

Springfever, Changing Date/Time on any equipment depends on that particular Model.

So if you search for manual on your phone's model, There should be instructions on how to correct date/time. On my phone, I have to press Menu --> Settings --> Set Date/Time.

Again same thing with cameras, instructions depend on Manufacturer/Model. But for newer cameras, once you press Menu, you should be able to navigate to settings where you can change it.

newbee newbee
May '13

I just showed the picture to my husband without any explanation and he said mountain lion.

I can understand why the second picture looks like a muscular deer, but the other two clearly show feline. I don't understand the reason behind arguing about it or insisting it's something else.

Tracy Tracy
May '13

Tracy clearly your husband needs glasses it is clearly a coyote even in the second picture you can clearly see the long snout even into shadow and I have seen coyotes and all different colors it's not a mountain line I have spent over 50 years in the woods of New Jersey believe me it's a coyote case closed

oldred
May '13

LOL, Tracy, I just showed the pictures to my husband without explanation and he said coyote.

To me, the gait does not look like the classic overstep walk that mountain lions use. The legs are also quite long and look pretty spindly to me. I've been searching for a picture of a mountain lion standing at attention like in the middle picture and I haven't found anything like that.

So I guess that's the reasoning behind arguing about it. I don't think it's very clear.

Aquarius Aquarius
May '13

DH, do you know why that was never made public?

If all you say is true, that should have been reported as a public safety caution / warning. People need to be aware of this and be alert when out in the woods or near water sources or farms with animals.

It's a sad state of affairs when residents of NJ have to look to other states Wildlife Agencies to get educated in big cat safety. NJ needs to set the record straight and do the right thing.

Thank you newbe, we tried the manual directions and it didn't work.

Spring Fever
May '13

If muteman were to state the location as to where he took these pictures, then word would get out and you will have the crazies going out with their guns looking to execute this thing and have a trophy kill. I say let the NJ Fish and Game handle this. I wouldn't give the location either. He did right with calling police and letting them handle it. Hopefully he will be tranquilized and re-located but in the meantime, keep your cats indoors and watch your dogs when they are let out.

villani villani
May '13

You caught us spring fever I have two come clean it is a vast conspiracy New Jersey fish and wildlife are breeding attack mountain lions for homeland security so that the Muslim brotherhood and the gray Panthers can take over America the attack mountain lions are to be used at the FEMA camps to keep the people in line and to also carry ammunition for the Muslim Panthers

oldred
May '13

To me it looks like a miniature horse.

4paws 4paws
May '13

4paws, I thought something like a horse too. The legs look like a hoofed animal's. I really don't get feline. Canine, maybe. It's definitely interesting.

Aquarius Aquarius
May '13

Lol 4paws - I actually thought the same thing!

Rebecka Rebecka
May '13

My first thought was dog. The one picture with the nose is what looks like a horse.

It's so far away, a lot is going to be a guess. A sense of scale isn't easy either. When you try to zoom in, what looks like tail may not be tail after all. If it was a mountain lion even what seems to be a tail at a distance, the tail isn't long enough. It should be much longer than ground length, bushy, and curled up at the bottom. The tail seems to be definitely bigger than a bobcat, but not to the ground. The proportion of legs seems to be too tall to be feline. But the upper and lower leg ratio is clearly not deer, but probably not feline either.


Well oldred said case closed, so case closed.

My point about the arguing is that it isn't clear what the animal is, at least to everyone but oldred. I don't understand why the need to insist you know what it is for certain, when you weren't there and it's a photograph. So silly.

Tracy Tracy
May '13

We could argue forever about what animal is in the photos, but it's certainly not a mountain lion. The head and snout are a dead giveaway. The elongated snout is especially apparent if you look at the shadow on the ground in the middle image rather than the animal itself and compare that to cougar profiles.


Reading this thread for the first time and with all of this speculation going on..I decided to ask my husband what he saw in the posted pictures on this thread without hesitation.....he said "Mountain Lion"....He also said he saw plenty of them in Wyoming so he is sure that is what it is...

joyful joyful
May '13

Oldred, you are quite the character!

Just for the record, in my last post, I was speaking to the comment made by
DH regarding the police and an animal control person supposedly removing a sleeping mt. lion from along the river. My comments were made to point out that, if the story was true, it should have been followed up with an article in the paper with a caution to the public regarding big cat safety...since the NJ Fish and Wildlife are too
afraid to go public with the information they have received over the years. I know- no pictures.

Point number two, you should probably sit down for this one...I am now using an I Pad and am able to get a much clearer picture of the animal and I actually agree with you that said animal may just be a coyote! I still can not clearly see the tail or the length of the fur on the animal which still leaves room for doubt in my mind, but if I were a gambling person, which I am not, I would wager on the side of coyote...

So there!

Spring Fever
May '13

Tracy it's obvious that you need glasses to I have seen hundreds upon hundreds of coyotes in my lifetime and have watched them for hours at a time from a distance of a few feet to a couple thousand believe me it's not a mountain lion the pictures of this animal clearly shows an animal in the canine family whether it's a dog coyote or a hybrid I have spent my entire life in the great outdoors and have never seen anything that would make me think that there is a breeding population of mountain lions in New Jersey like I have said before with the 10's of thousands of hunters in New Jersey with their thousands upon thousands of trail cameras you would think in the last 20 years one person would get a picture of one most of these trail cameras are on game trails and that is the exact place where you would expect a mountain lion to be

oldred
May '13

And by the way I have seen big cats in the wild . I have seen actual wild mountain lions in California and tigers in the jungles of Vietnam

oldred
May '13

I'm saying coyote with a touch of mange. To upright and elongated legs for mt.lion. I have seen a bunch of recent pics of live mt. lions and they are much more muscular and move closer to the ground.

fishmaker1 fishmaker1
May '13

oldred, I wear contacts, thanks. For the record, I don't really care what the animal is. I just don't understand why you're so insistent. Does it really matter?

Tracy Tracy
May '13

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

Coyote...


@ Muteman, you can use your Nikon Cool Pix camera and zoom the pic in the camera and repost. That is a great camera that is capable of doing a lot of things. It can also shoot quality video too!


This last picture looks like no coyote I have ever seen and I have seen quite a few as I lived in Ca for a couple of years and I have seen several in Jersey. I do however believe the photo is real. I really do think it was a feline I could be wrong. One puzzling thing to me was the pd was not overly surprised by the cat. He also stated he had seen it before. IDK if he thought it was a Lynx or Bobcat or if he was aware of that type of feline. I really do believe it was a large feline. If domestic I hate to see the owners dogs. I will post location tomorrow once I hear back from fish and game.

muteman muteman
May '13

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

Here is a zoomed in photo of 1st image

muteman muteman
May '13

Here you go mute man...

http://www.northjersey.com/news/063010_NJ_officials_Coyotes_no_greater_worry_for_residents.html?scpromo=1


I will also say look at the underside shading the coyote does not have the light fur

muteman muteman
May '13

thanks for the info

muteman muteman
May '13

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

here is zoomed of last image. again you can see the tail if you look

muteman muteman
May '13

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

Zoom of 2nd image

muteman muteman
May '13

For some reasons I feel the urge to visit a zoo during weekend.


Weird animal...almost looks like a goat's head.

Martha Martha
May '13

legs to long, body to short I think this is BS

just sayin
May '13

Thats not a mountain lion, Not sure what it is, but with a long snoot like that its not feline.


Could this be the elusive Jersey Devil?


Agreed... not feline. Looks like a cross between a fox and coyote to me.

JeffersonRepub JeffersonRepub
May '13

I've reviewed the pics and I am fairly certain that it is a Liger.

Chilly Ned
May '13

it's clearly, unequivocally, a dog-deer mixed breed,

legs like a deer , snout like a dog, tail like a coyote, no question about it

case closed. Anyone who says different is a blind idiot who needs pills, booze and glasses, I have spent all of my life in the woods behind Village Green and live under a rock, so I know wherefore whatever I am talking about, so there.

BrotherDog BrotherDog
May '13

LOL Chilly Ned!

Lady Jayne Lady Jayne
May '13

Liyote - from Cervidae family, new mammal from Northwestern New Jersey.

My niece got a Sphynx cat a few years ago. We are still in a process of discussing if it's a feline or something belonging to genus Rattus. It looks like an animal who survived Chernobyl disaster. No offense to Sphynx fans.


check out a savanah cat.. We had one in boonton

deangeliscc deangeliscc
May '13

Muteman, oh how I wish you were right in this case, just to shut some of the nay-sayers up who continually stick their heads in the sand when it comes to the topic of mt lions being sighted in various locations in NJ...

However, I have spent many minutes this morning searching web sites for mangy coyote pictures and healthy coyotes fur coloring. I found good images of both. There are coyotes with the exact coloring in your picture, right down to the light fur or skin coloring on the inside portion of the legs, and to the black fur on the tip of their medium length tail if comparing to a mt. Lion's tail or a Bobcat's. There are of course other differences too, but I was specifically looking for the above.

I won't belabor the point. Everyone is free to draw their own conclusions on your pictures. I give you credit for grabbing your wife's camera and posting here. Keep it up because one day, someone IS going to get that picture or find acceptable proof to deposit on the NJ Fish and Wildlife's doorstep. I for one will celebrate!

Spring Fever
May '13

I for one can't wait to hear what this animal turns out to be. I still say it looks like a miniature horse.
Please keep us posted as to what fish and game says it is. You zoomed in the pictures but they do not enlarge and they are blurry.

4paws 4paws
May '13

What's a liger " Only the coolest animal ever" great movie. IDK have not heard anything back from NJ Fish and Game but all 3 of us who witnessed it seem to think feline in nature. Funny thing went back over to site today to see if I could see it again or tracks. I did get pics of a track but IDK i will have to look up on internet before I get abused by everyone here. Although I think I got lime as I was covered with about 30 ticks in about 1 hour worth of walking.

muteman muteman
May '13

The pics of the track I got was canine. Watwahwaaaa

muteman muteman
May '13

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

Where is Marlin Perkins when you need him!?!


great obscure pull of day Greg!

muteman muteman
May '13

I want to clarify the distance is about 100 to 150 yds and taken from step on passenger side door. It really sucks because I was talking to pd and the animal was in the brush then it came out and made its way along path as wife snapped pics from car. I know it is really hard for certain to say from a couple of pics but we all agreed as to some kind of cat. What sucks even more is camera does have video capability but we were caught in moment and did not even think to use it as we never use camera for video.

muteman muteman
May '13

1st Pic is a mountain Lion. 2nd is a small nilgai. 3rd is a coyote. So it has to be an Indian Shaman shape-shifting.

One-Eyed Poacher One-Eyed Poacher
May '13

Its a chupacabra!!!!! (which also turned out to be a mangy coyote)

I don't understand how there is even a question here. The third photo shows a distinct elongated snout. It's some kind of dog, and most likely a yote.

Gadfly Gadfly
May '13

We saw it too

Paula22
May '13

I have been using Mountain Lion urine to keep the deer out of the garden, maybe it's time to go back to Wolf urine. Don't want to draw them cats any closer. I have enough excitement surprising bears at night. One night they won't be as surprised as me.

One-Eyed Poacher One-Eyed Poacher
May '13

Hee Haw!!

Swampy Swampy
May '13

Bobcats in Morris County - http://www.dailyrecord.com/article/20130726/NJNEWS/307260023/


Bobcat eating rabbit in Green Township - http://www.nj.com/warrenreporter/index.ssf/2013/07/bobcat_spotted_eating_rabbit_i.html#incart_river


HELP!! I'm PUZZLED and a little worried!!! On my way to pick up my son fr. work last Friday on Airport Rd. (Green Township) when I saw a baby bear crossing; not a big deal. I thought, I've seen bigger! Twenty feet after, 3 deer were running and almost hitting my van. Now, this time I thought the mama bear must be around. Almost passing the mini Airport on my left and a big construction on my right, when suddenly about 100-150 feet to the right coming out of the woods was appeared to be a black mama bear... so I thought. Then it did a quick dive, pinning a deer down; exposing a big very thick long tail!!! It was way too large to be a regular black cat. I thought it was a bob cat or a mountain lion but it had pure shiny black fur. I thought it could have been a puma or a panther but puzzled! I couldn't understand how I could be seeing a black panther in New Jersey?!?! Are black panthers indigenous here?! Have any of you seen a black panther around here?!

Rebecca Dionne Rebecca Dionne
Jun '14

What you saw was a mountain lion,I saw it a few times,it hunts on the golf course at night sometimes.You can hear the screams of the geese and other animals.This thing ran in front of me in front of Mattars one day.Wild life management told me they will never catch it, its too smart to be caught. Bring your cats in at night,and watch walking your dogs at night in Panther Valley,I lived there and this is no joke,the one I saw was about 130 lbs.The darker color is something he picked up,could be cross breed. They come up from the appalacian trail, it pass right through Jersey.


Could've been Mantis Man searching for feral children.


Just guessing coyote, they do come in pure black. Coyotes have been in the 60-70 pound range people even giving higher numbers. One never knows these days, but until proof of big cats I will stick with yotes.

fishmaker1 fishmaker1
Jul '14

Saw a large cat like this last week Jan, 2017, in Summit NJ. Thought it was just a very large fat cat or bob cat from Watchung mountain reservation. Only saw it from behind but noticed that it was not delicate like cats it was more like a teddy bear cat , husky and like the size of a small dog. Mostly concerned because its coat was not common striped bobcat color it was black which after checking internet pictures, leads me to believe now that it was a panther cub.


More likely a bear cub, or coyote (which come in many color phases from gray to almost black). Especially last week with the warm weather.

Agust Agust
Jan '17

Besides a bear cub, depending on the size, it could well be a fisher as well given the color. I would figure the chances of a fisher are greater than a coyote that color. But no panther.


I live in independence and down the street from us a friend has a mountain lion on a trail cam. Scrawny about 75 pounds. They are in this area. But I hear the state denies it. Not sure why.

Mr Happy Mr Happy
Jan '17

At 75 pounds, its much more likely to be a lynx, bobcat or coyote than a (small lions are over 100 pounds). The reason the state "denies" it is because there have been hundreds of reports, all and I mean every one of them that has been followed up on has been debunked. Almost always its bobcat, coyote or an actual cat or dog. Every and I mean every "trailcam" picture that has been posted has been determined to be fake, many are tracked back to originals from Wyoming, California or even Alaska. Including the 3-4 different ones purported to be from Salem County a couple years back.

While it is certainly possible, so far there have been hundreds of false claims and not a single verifiable one. To me that means, unless there is actual DNA or a verifiable clean picture from a reliable original source (not my neighbors buddy has) mountain lions in NJ are no different than bigfoot in NJ or an honest man in Congress.

Agust Agust
Jan '17

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

"a friend has a mountain lion on a trail cam"

Mark Mc. Mark Mc.
Jan '17

Please post a pic!

Rebecka Rebecka
Jan '17

Mr Happy - Do you remember the "mountain lion" in Netcong? "Mountain Lion!". "Mountain Lion". "Positively confirmed mountain lion". "It's a sheriff's deputy so he **KNOWS**!!!". "Confirmed!". Then the picture came with a tiny powder puff tail? Everyone and their uncle says they have a mountain lion on their trail cam and then every pic shows positively it's a bobcat.


I 100 percent saw a large black cat over the summer in pv...we thought it was a black dog...walking down the street in the meadows section of PV. With all the cleared land I wouldn't be surprised if someone's "home" was disrupted

PV res
Jan '17

A highly respected Hackettstown official saw a large wild cat running behind the Hackettstown HMUA headquarters around 2 months ago. I believe this is real.

MansfieldResident MansfieldResident
Jan '17

I believe this is a bobcat, Mansfieldresident! Surprising and neat to see, but not rare. And not cougar.

kepa
Jan '17

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

I have seen many bobcats and this doesn't look like a bobcat to me. As far as size I am not an expert or hunter.

Mr Happy Mr Happy
Jan '17

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

I have also seen many bobcats and this doesn't look like a bobcat to me. As far as size I am not a expert or hunter. This is from my trail cam!

John C John C
Jan '17

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

'Allo Kitty! It looks like someone disturbed you from your slumber on their trail cam. Naughty human.


I have also seen many bobcats and I can say I do not believe I am a bobcat either. I might be a bettycat but definitely not bobcat. Actually I'm a sweetcat so they call me 'Sugar'. As far as size I am not a expert or hunter either. Well actually I do hunt mowseburger. This is from my trail cam. In my natural habitat of my "den". I love HackCATStown! ;-)

Sugar Sugar
Jan '17

"I have seen many bobcats and this doesn't look like a bobcat to me."

So two questions:

What town was that photo taken in?

Does he have *any* other photos taken from the same trail cam with that boulder in the frame?

Mark Mc. Mark Mc.
Jan '17

Agreed, Mr. Happy - looks more like a mountain lion than a bobcat.

Would love to be able to verify that location as well, but suffice it to say that a mountain lion caught on trail cam in Independence would not surprise me, personally, in the least.

Rebecka Rebecka
Jan '17

Mountain Lion struck by car yesterday in Warren County... http://fox2now.com/2017/01/23/mountain-lion-struck-by-car-on-i-70-in-warren-county/

...Missouri.

mohepinoke mohepinoke
Jan '17

Google reverse image search shows that photo has been kicking around the internet for awhile, Mr Happy
Here is one forum saying it's from Franklin NJ in 2014 http://www.mtbnj.com/forum/threads/wildcat-in-wildcat.34652/page-4

kepa
Jan '17

Kepa - That's why I wanted him to say what town it was from before posting anything else. If his friend said Independence I'd then ask why the discrepancy (another site said that same picture was from Lafayette).

http://www.newjerseyhunter.com/forums/73-general-comments-information/208721-yet-another-nj-mountain-lion-sighting-lol.html

Also, all the pictures are always from someone's nameless friend, never the original photographer.

Mark Mc. Mark Mc.
Jan '17

I don't know... looks like a cougar to me!


Looks like an undated, unspecified, credit-less photo of a cougar to me too, Kris!

kepa
Jan '17

It was supposedly taken on Petersburg Road in Independence. The guy who claims it was real and is a very low key person and down to earth. I asked him a bunch of times is the location real and he stated anyone that wants to see the rock and tree are more than welcome. I didn't look cause guite frankly I wasn't concerned and to busy with business and family. Next time I see him I will question authenticity.

Mr Happy Mr Happy
Jan '17

https://youtu.be/DpiNIu13fzE .

This is my friends video she lives on video behind PV.

Theresa Theresa
Jan '17

*Warning* "Black Cat" Sighting Feb 3 2017
Mt Bethel Road, Mansfield/Hackettstown NJ

To my surprise I found this recent thread after doing a "black panther sighting nj" google search after seeing what appeared to be a black cat that resembled a medium-large sized dog. At approximately 1AM, I was driving on Mt Bethel road in the Hackettstown/Port Murray/Mansfield Area. Within a half or so mile of reaching rockport Road in Port Murray, I saw two glowing green eyes glaring in my headlights off in the distance. As I got closer, rolling by at 30 or so MPH I expected to see typical wildlife or a house cat, to my surprise the figure was all black, long tale, large agile body, resembled that of a notable black panther, carfully maneuvering through heavy foliage than running off in the wood line going east towards Rockport. I'm not claiming this was a confirmed 100% "Panther" sighting but it visually resembled that of a larger framed black cat. Just a heads up to those who live in the area especially those with young ones and animals/pets. Mansfield PD was notified.


https://patch.com/new-jersey/hackettstown/s/g5b98/bobcat-traps-long-valley-family-inside-their-bathroom?utm_source=facebook.com&utm_medium=social&utm_term=home+%26+garden&utm_campaign=autopost&utm_content=hackettstown

I think he just wanted to be their pet.

jrsemom jrsemom
Jun '17

Don't tell Rebecca!

skippy skippy
Jun '17

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

I live in Panther Valley off Bald Eagle Road, this animal was in my yard , does anybody know what type of animal this is?

Miiken Miiken
Jun '17

You've got a pretty red fox there, Miiken. They also come in a grey/silver color in NJ, too. Very striking animals.

Rebecka Rebecka
Jun '17

Unfortunately, the bobcat later attacked someone's dog and tested positive for rabies.

Jesse341 Jesse341
Jun '17

My parents used to own all of Panther Valley. My Dad's name was Robert S. Conahay and we built the mansion on the mountain in the 60's when we sold out to developers.I'm pretty sure I can solve this problem about the large cats you're seeing. They're panthers. We saw them all the time when I was growing up there......especially out by the limestone cliffs (but I don't know if the cliffs are still there. I am not at all familiar with your layout ) of course, there were always bobcats screaming at night, but the panthers were more scarce,almost shy. Like I said though, we often saw them. They always ran upon seeing any of us, so we were never worried. I'd be very careful these days though. I've seen them up close....WAY too close......and they're no joke !

Cassandra K. Conahay Cassandra K. Conahay
Jun '17

When you say "panther," I assume you mean "mountain lion?" ("Panther" can mean different types of large cats.)

Rebecka Rebecka
Jun '17

I have personally witnessed something exactly as in Mr Happy's photo run across the road in front of me up in sussex a few years back.

Me and 3 other people in the car saw it, as well as the four people in the car behind me.

They are definitely in NJ

Darrin Darrin
Jun '17

I just saw a Large BLACK cat this weekend in the woods of Hackettstown. It was about 160-180lbs and muscular. Twice the size of my dog so it was easy to estimate the weight.

Here's what happened....I was sitting quietly by myself enjoying nature in the woods for hours and I saw a black animal creeping 40 feet away from me but facing slightly away from me. I thought it was a small bear at first until I saw how muscular it was and realized it was a Large cat. When I saw it clearly and realized it was a Large cat... I gasped and it shot off into the woods, up the hill, very quickly and silently!

I don't think it wants anything to do with humans so I'm not posting out of fear... However they are predators so i could be a meal if it really was hungry. Anyhow it clearly didnt want to hang with me. But it was definately black.. Pitch black.. And definately NOT a bobcat, as i have seen plently of those. I just want everyone interested in these large cat sightings to know that September 2017 there has been another sighting in Hackettstown NJ bordering Warren and Sussex County.

ilovecats ilovecats
Sep '17

What area of woods in town?


Yes. This is what I saw in panther valley last year. My sister claims she saw a bobcat over the weekend. Would not surprise me with all the construction up there. Animals have nowhere to go.

Htown Htown
Sep '17

bobcats are pretty common around here. small, more elusive and a neat sight to see

kepa
Sep '17

I have seen a very large one in frelinghuysen in my head lights one night about a year ago
huge cat head large body and very long tail. this creature was huge

kevin
Nov '17

I was at Ghost Lake on 8/24/19 walking my dog with a friend and had a run in with a mountain lion. For those who know the area, there is a cave not far down the path that runs along the lake... It is part of the Jenny Jump State Park. Upon approaching the cave, we smelled some kind of dead animal. We both saw it at the same time lingering in the far back of the cave. A LARGE mountain lion staring back at us we could easily see as our eyes focused towards the back of the dark cave. It was not a black cat like some of the other posters on this forum claimed to have seen, but normal markings on its head and a tan body... easily over 120 pounds. We high tailed it out of there and lucky for us, the State Park Police were in the lot as we were leaving. We explained to the officer what we encountered, and he said he could smell the dead deer the cat was eating from the parking lot himself. He also stated he had seen mountain lions in the area himself, but never in this spot. He proceeded to use yellow tape to block off the entrance to the tail head. We left as another unmarked police car was pulling in.


We don't have a breeding population in NJ people. If you saw one it's likely a lone male straggler like the one that was killed in CT a few years ago. That one traveled from the Black Hills in the Dakotas up through Canada, to NY, to where it ultimately got killed in CT. They know this because it was tagged. We have plenty of Bobcats. You're saying it was 120lbs.... that's bigger than a German Shepherd dog.


Mountain lions are big cats. Males generally weigh 117 to 220 lbs., averaging 150 lbs. Females typically weigh between 64 and 141 lbs., averaging 121 lbs.

Calico696 Calico696
2 weeks ago

Thanks, Metsman. It was a very big cat. The Park Police officer acknowledge to me that he has seen them several times in the area while patrolling the state park, but not in the cave. I think they are way more common in the area than people think, especially considering our proximity to the Delaware Water Gap, PA and the Port Jervis area of NY, where they are known to be. I think its far more likely it came from there, rather than CT. A trip from CT which would require the cat to make a far journey through residential and suburban areas of the state. I have lived in the area my entire life.... the only thing between the Delaware Water Gap and Allamuchy where I saw the cat is farms and heavily wooded rolling hills. Plenty of dead deer and other animals along route 80 for them to snack on as well.


You're missing my point. There is no breeding population east of the Mississippi except a small population in Michigan. Sometimes young males make long treks like the one in CT. The males are territorial and will get driven out of an area occupied by another male.


Easy there Metsman. don't get your panties in a bunch LOL. I don't think I am disagreeing with you or anyone else... It could have migrated, maybe not. At the end of the day, there has been little to no research done on the topic that I am aware of in a very long time and therefore its pretty presumptuous for you or anyone else to claim they know something like that for sure. If you're basing your 'point' on one cat that they found and tracked, I think its disingenuous to say that's the exact case for all of them. Not a very big sample size. Maybe not, you sound like you have a biology degree from somewhere....


Ive spotted them in port murray and long valley so there is breeding. They are very illusive so sightings are scarce. They have been around for a while.

Sandy Tomlinson Sandy Tomlinson
2 weeks ago

Where are the pictures?


Fish and Game employs wildlife biologists. I'm sure they're doing field studies all the time across the state.


About six weeks ago I was running on the trail/road at Deer Park (allamuchy south) I ran from the first parking lot, past the second parking lot and toward the large pond/lake (is t called deer park pond?) with the dam at the one end.

As I was coming up to where the woods opens up and you can see the lake on the left hand side, I saw what I first thought was a dog, then a deer and then, to my horror, was 95% sure I was looking at a tan mountain lion. It was maybe 150ft away but I could tell It had a very long tail and round head. It’s legs were beefier than a dog or certainly a deer. A few seconds glimpse is all I got as it skulked away into the woods opposite the lake.

I thought I was seeing things. Maybe I was. I did some short research when I got home and decided I must have been mistaken because they are supposedly extinct from this area and have been for 100 years. This thread is making me think that what I saw was really a mountain lion/cougar/panther. Needless to say, I’ve been running at other parks since then.

Consigliere
2 weeks ago

I have seen one in my yard. It was stalking a cat. Scared the bejesus out of me. We had heard what sounded like a mountain lion calling in the woods the week before. It was gone before I could take a picture.. But I agree.. Take pictures people. Our phones now have the camera option readily available for a quick memory shot. No memory like a mountain lion that's for sure

chef peder chef peder
2 weeks ago

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2018/01/north-american-eastern-cougar-mountain-lion-extinct-spd/

I find it hard to believe you're all seeing Mountain Lions.


Every single reported lion sighting has been proven to be either a coyote or a bobcat. Usually by a real biologist examining the tracks or the doing DNA analysis of the fur. I saw my first bobcat this weekend, but it was in Colorado. Big fella for a bobcat, but the short tail gave it away. (BTW there are mountain lions near RMNP where I saw the cat.)

Sorry unless you have a picture and or actual physical evidence I will remain a skeptic.


Jono and Agust, I would have loved to snap a photo on my phone but I high tailed it to my car. There have been plenty of others who have posted videos and photos. To summarize see below:

http://www.newjerseyhunter.com/forums/73-general-comments-information/208721-yet-another-nj-mountain-lion-sighting-lol.html

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4kalaFCOqzA

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQn2Sf4aWf8

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_M3GKFTSKI

Metsman - can you send me a link to the research? If they have them, they're public information. NJ posts the results of all scientific studies performed. For example, here's the 2018 Annual Fishing report which details the results of a study on stocked trout in the Big Flat Brook and Flat Brook... https://www.njfishandwildlife.com/pdf/fwfisheries/reports/annualreport18.pdf


LMAO are you kidding me with that last video. That was a house cat....


Don’t know why people are in such disbelief that mountain lions don’t exist here. Any animal can migrate, there is nothing keeping them to just one spot.


F&G does not normally issue reports saying they did not find something. NJ Non Game and Endangered species has many studies on bobcat and coyote. If they had t issue a report on every person that reported a bobcat as a mountain lion, they would never get any actual work done. Same for all the folks who claim the coyote they saw is actually a wolf, because coyotes cannot possibly be that big. (They are).

They also have not issued any reports on the lack of Bigfoot, or endangered Jersey Devil or the Hookerman.


CS, the first link you posted, from newjerseyhunter website is a post MAKING FUN of people who say they have a photo of a mountain lion. They were making fun that someone again was just re-using a photo that has been used for years all over.


Agust, Agreed... my point is that there has been no funds allocated to the research. Just a little crazy to me that there have literally been hundreds of sightings, acknowledgement from authorities, but some are still in disbelief.

I'll tell you what, here are the coordinates of where I saw it.. was only 4 days ago. Take a walk down the path after parking in the lot (assuming the yellow tape is down that the Park Police put up) and poke your head in the cave there...here are your coordinates. 40.923116, -74.892929


Rich, and the others?


Hundreds of sightings but no pictures


Jono since i dont run or rock climb with a phone pictures arent happening. I have lived in this area for 60 ish years and in the last 20 i have seen 5.
This year ive come up on bears more than any time. 5 last month in different spots. Seems like they have really increased. Wildlife seems to be adapting to us.

Sandy Tomlinson Sandy Tomlinson
2 weeks ago

bug3 - There have been loads of pictures that goes with the number of sightings. The only issue is those pictures (like the links) have all turned out to be bobcats. That's what our F&G friends are trying to tell us. ;-)


Sandy I would place bets you either saw bobcats or housecats. 5 sightings? Cmon.... Everyone has seen a bear around here. I've seen coyote dead on the side of the road and in the woods while hunting. There's no proof of mountain lions. The only proof we had was of a lone male mountain lion a few years back that traveled a long way and got hit by a car in CT. For you to have 5 sightings in the past 20 years would mean there's a breeding population which there is not and that is proven. The Eastern Cougar is extinct and there are yet to be breeding populations from western mountain lions in neighboring states west of here. They're not here.


I am with the skeptics and would go so far as to say I don’t believe they exist out here. I have spent many hours and days hiking in the backcountry out west and have spoken to many park rangers, other hikers, etc. who have spent much more time in areas where lions maintain breeding populations than I have, and with the exception of 1-2 people, no one had EVER seen one, including rangers who have spent 25+ years in the wilderness. Cougars are notoriously elusive and reclusive and generally shun contact with humans. So I find it extremely hard to believe that not only are sightings occurring in NJ, but that people are reporting numerous sightings over a number of years. That picture from “Lafayette “ has been making the rounds online for years and IIRC came from a trail cam in Colorado. To date, there has been no hard evidence of a lion in NJ in over 100 years. Show me the evidence and I will become a believer


They have been In the area for well over 10 yrs. Brought back for deer population management at one point. Knew of a farmer in the blairstown/Sussex area who spotted one around his farm animals. He told authorities. They told him he probably saw something else. So he said ok, I'll shoot it next time and bring it to you. They told him he would be arrested. After he did some questioning to people he knew, he found out they were brought in the area.

Itiswhatitis
2 weeks ago

I am sure some others have 'migrated' from other areas in recent yrs, tagging proved it

Itiswhatitis
2 weeks ago

Metsman. Having hitchhiked in 1980 from here to Alaska, thru the Yukon territory, to Wa. state, back across to here, camped in the rockies, southwest, up and down the Appalachian trail, in the heart of Tenn. and all thru NY state and Pa, I think I have had close encounters with alot of wild life. Bobcats do not have long tails anywhere in the north American continent. Wolves are larger than mtn. lions. Cyotes look like dogs. Cougars look like very large cats. Ive seen them in Fla. The ones here are very simular.

Sandy Tomlinson Sandy Tomlinson
2 weeks ago

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)

Kind of like the BFRO thinks there's bigfoot everywhere. LOL...

I would say in time they could migrate from out west to here. But guess what.... That has to happen in places like PA and Ohio first. They don't have breeding populations either.


Wow, when you google “NJ cougars” you certainly get an eyeful ;-)

Strangerdanger Strangerdanger
2 weeks ago

I would put my money on it being a bobcat no way it’s a mountain lion


I spend hours and hours in the forest - at Jenny Jump … I hunt whitetail deer and have cameras out for nearly 6 months at a time … I have never seen a big cat... I have seen coyotes but that is it … Yes it possible but highly unlikely we have any big cats in the area …

LibertyThinker LibertyThinker
2 weeks ago

The Cat-Files: I Want to Believe

Unfortunately, all the belief in the world doesn't change the fact, there is no resident population of mountain lions east of the Mississippi, other than a very small population of mountain lions in Florida. Although there have been confirmed sightings in the U.P. of Michigan, there is no evidence of a breeding population.

And BTW, there's never been a report of a melanistic (i.e. black) mountain lion. The classic "black panther" is a jaguar from South America.


Just had a large coyote pass thru our yard. I could easily see how it could be taken as a mountain lion because it was That. Big.
I bet it weighed 60 pounds.


Back to the Top | View all Forum Topics

Leave a Reply

To comment on this topic, fill out the form below. If you would like to comment directly to one person, you may click on the envelope next to the posters name if they provided their email.

Re: Please be Careful! (Re: Large cat, Panther Valley)
Name (Required)
Email (Protected)
Add Photo (Optional)
By pressing Submit Comment, you are agreeing to the terms and conditions.